| The first
rule of financial aid is simple: The colleges are the place
to find it. About 95 percent of the available dollars are administered
through them, including virtually all of the federal money and most
state grants. We'll suggest other places to look later on, but this
chapter focuses solely on money that comes by virtue of applying for
financial aid at a college.
As we have noted, college-administered financial aid comes in two
basic varieties: awards based on academic merit or special talents,
and awards based on need. Your first major decision in the financial-aid
search is whether or not to apply for need-based aid. In most cases,
the answer should be yes. Even if your family income is over $100,000,
there is still a chance that you may qualify for something, and
some non-need awards require an aid application. We recommend that
you sit down with your parents at the outset of the college search
and ask a simple question: How much can the family afford to pay
each year for college? A ballpark figure will do. Next, compare
that number with the total of tuition, room and board, and fees
(plus at least $2,500 for travel, books, and living expenses) at
the college(s) you are interested in attending. If the total of
those is larger than what your parents feel they can afford, you
should definitely apply for financial aid.
The talk with your parents should inject a dose of reality into
your college search. If the figure they can pay is below the cost
of your schools, you need to investigate some cheaper options. But
don't eliminate the expensive ones just yet. Apply for aid and see
what you can get. The time to judge whether a college is too expensive
comes at the end of the process, after the financial-aid awards
have been made. Only then will you know the actual out-of-pocket
costs of each school.
To illustrate this point, we offer the following example. Let's
assume that a close personal friend of yours named Todd Tight-Wad
is applying to two schools: an expensive private college charging
$30,000 per year and a state university with a more modest sticker
price of $10,000. Which one do you think will end up costing Todd's
family more? The one that costs $30,000, right? Maybe-but maybe
not.
When Todd applies for financial aid, the system reviews his family's
assets and calculates something called the Expected Family Contribution
(EFC)-the amount Todd's family can afford for college. Let's say
his family's EFC is $7,000. If the colleges are willing and able,
they'll give Todd financial aid to cover what they consider to be
his "demonstrated need"-the difference between the EFC
calculated by the aid formula and their sticker price. At the expensive
private college, he would qualify for $23,000 in aid, while at the
public university he would get only $3,000. Even though the sticker
prices of the two are vastly different, they both end up costing
him $7,000. Even if his EFC were much higher-$15,000 or so-he would
still qualify for $15,000 from the private college to help soften
the blow. In a few cases, the expensive college might actually turn
out to be cheaper. Public universities are typically much less generous
with need-based aid than private ones, and if the private one meets
Todd's full demonstrated need while the public one meets none of
it, the pricey $30,000 private school turns out to be $3,000 cheaper
when all is said and done.
For an early indication of how the system might work for your family,
we recommend that you complete one of the financial aid estimators
that are available via the World Wide Web. (Some financial aid offices
also make them available on paper or via their web sites.) These
programs replicate the aid formulas used to calculate need. Simply
plug in your family's financial data, and voilà-out comes
the EFC. For thoroughness and reliability, we recommend the College
Board's aid estimator on its Web site at www.collegeboard.com.
If you and your parents are careful with your data, the estimator
should give a rough idea of how much aid you can expect. The results
will help dictate your financial aid strategy. If your EFC is over
$25,000, your best hope of significant aid probably lies in merit
scholarships. If your EFC is less than $10,000, you'll want to look
at schools with a firm commitment to need-based aid.
We emphasize that an aid estimator will give only a ballpark figure,
and their predictive ability is less for those who have complicated
finances. With college purse strings pulled tighter every year,
the financial-aid system is less reliable than ever before. Families
can no longer sit back and trust that they'll get all the money
they need. One essential strategy is to apply to one or more schools
where you are sure your family can pay the sticker price. Second,
you and your parents should do a thorough job of financial aid comparison
shopping before you apply. The new world of financial aid has more
twists and turns than a Stephen King thriller. The time has come
to move beyond Financial Aid 101.
|